The CODOH Revisionist Forum

So I've read Hans. I don't suppose you know where I can put eyes on NS-19 other than to, you know, go to Europe, or to the district of Columbia, do you? How about the wartime provisioning documents? Any ideas where to look? You aware of any audits of the system, internal audits? Documentation. NS ...

Good luck with your research!

You should consider that we are primarily not looking for Jews fit for heavy forced labour. We are actually seeking those considered unfit for heavy work.

Stubble, the "Chełmno" (German Kulm) mentioned in the cited testimony is an entirely different place than "Chełmno nad Nerem" (German Kulmhof) where the Nazi extermination camp was located. These places are more than 150 km apart. It's like if you think two different Madisons in the US are the same.

Have you read this book Hans? If not I think you should be ashamed to be peddling this stuff as if it is definitive proof. Yes, I have read the book and I agree with Munro's assessment that the photographs picture a homicidal gas van at Sonderkommando 7a. Assessment? Hmmm? Sounds then like its just ...

By the way, recently contemporary photographs of the type of homicidal gas van also employed in Chelmno were published (taken in April 1942 by Einsatzgruppe B's Sonderkommando 7a): https://holocaustcontroversies.blogspot.com/2025/07/first-published-photographs-of-nazi.html Thanks for sharing. It's ...

Have you read this book Hans? If not I think you should be ashamed to be peddling this stuff as if it is definitive proof. Yes, I have read the book and I agree with Munro's assessment that the photographs picture a homicidal gas van at Sonderkommando 7a. I'm also trying to obtain the images myself ...

If I'm being honest Archie, I don't think these trial minutes are going to prove a holocaust at chelmno. People don't get a couple years in prison for murdering over a hundred thousand people. You should not put your own perspective - or today’s standards - on the West German judicial system of the ...

I have never considered Chelmno much of a priority, but I do have one point that I am curious about which you may know the answer to if you have reviewed this material. There is a well-known war-time report called the Szlamek report yeah, heard about it: https://holocausthistory.site/1942-02-00 ...

The tidbit at the end however was as unnecessary as it would be for me to tell you to piss up a rope. Makes for a spicy exchange, but, it doesn't do much for constructive dialogue. Honestly, spending 2 weeks travelling to Ludwigsburg, Chelmno, Warsaw — combined with sightseeing — is not exactly unb ...

The tidbit at the end however was as unnecessary as it would be for me to tell you to piss up a rope. Makes for a spicy exchange, but, it doesn't do much for constructive dialogue. Honestly, spending 2 weeks travelling to Ludwigsburg, Chelmno, Warsaw - combined with sightseeing - is not exactly ...

I have never considered Chelmno much of a priority, but I do have one point that I am curious about which you may know the answer to if you have reviewed this material. There is a well-known war-time report called the Szlamek report yeah, heard about it: https://holocausthistory.site/1942-02-00 ...

Polish investigations and postwar trial records are digitized and available for on-site review at the IPN (Instytut Pamięci Narodowej) in Warsaw or its branches (e.g., Łodz, if you are visiting Chełmno anyway). The records of West-German investigations coordinated under the Zentrale Stelle der La ...

I recommend the following reading materials for your educational journey: Sonderkommando Kulmhof in German Documents - Body Disposal https://holocaustcontroversies.blogspot.com/2017/09/sonderkommando-kulmhof-in-german12.html Sonderkommando Kulmhof in German Documents - Body Disposal (Appendix) https ...

No, it really could not, since the "Alte Judenrampe" neither went into any of the camps (it literally stopped midway between Birkenau and Auschwitz Main Camp, after which you'd have to walk by foot or drive to the camps) nor was it a "dedicated enclosed area of the camp". And in no way was it a ...

Exactly. The new ramp went straight into the Birkenau camp with a track crossing right between the two Crematoria, which were enclosed. The old ramp didn't even go into a camp, let alone into 'dedicated enclosed areas of the camp'. This anachronism demonstrates the report couldn't possibly date ...