Recently, Nessie has made the following statements on this forum: I assert the proposition of mass murders is true, because of the evidence to prove it is true... The reason why the mass murder of millions of Jews had been settled as fact, is because of the evidence... You have cherry picked the ...
I like the way you dodge providing evidence, whilst criticising me for a lack of rigour! Nessie, if you were challenged to provide evidence for... oh, lets say the physical evidence for huge mass graves filled with the remains of hundreds and hundreds of thousands of people that you believed ...
Nessie wrote: ↑Wed Apr 23, 2025 6:17 am
I assert the proposition of mass murders is true, because of the evidence to prove it is true
Does that evidence include the discovery of the exact location of huge mass graves filled with the remains of hundreds and hundreds of thousands of people?
Therein lies revisionism's largest problem. The lack of evidence of the... accommodating, feeding, clothing and guarding millions of Jews, which would leave a lot of evidence. Instead, there is none. Nessie, would the digging of numerous massive pits and filling them with hundreds and hundreds of ...
...You have cherry picked the weakest form of evidence of all... Oh, so there are different "forms" of evidence, and some forms of evidence are weaker than others. Thanks for making that distinction. So here's your task for today Nessie (after you get done answering the numerous questions you are ...
The reason why the mass murder of millions of Jews had been settled as fact, is because of the evidence. That is also the reason why the death camp staff put on trial, never denied that those camps were used for mass murder and instead they tried to minimise their personal responsibility. Nessie ...
Himmler could have only given hearsay evidence about the day to day operation of Kremas and hearsay is not normally allowed in courts. Speaking of courts Nessie; Are there different levels of proof / proven - Yes. - or - No. ?? Nessie, you claim that something can be "proven" by a conversion of ...
I would expect mass graves that had been dug into to exhume the corpses, to not be perfectly rectangular. Chelmno was found to have a series of rectilinear pits. TII also had such identified during the geophysical survey. Belzec and Sobibor were more irregular again, indicating more digging. Nessie ...
Nessie wrote: ↑Mon Apr 28, 2025 10:41 am
You are not using converging evidence, you are using the logically flawed argument from incredulity.
Nessie, in this "convergence of evidence" method you use to allege that the jewish holocaust of WW II has been proven, do some forms of evidence have more evidential value than others?
There is only one definition of an eyewitness and the clue is in the name. Someone saw with their own eyes what they then later speak about. They actually witnessed the event as it happened. They likely did not see the entire event and they will have witnessed it with a different perspective to ...
You know that, yet you still regard all witnesses as equal. :? Neither Himmler nor Vrba were eyewitnesses, so their use as witnesses is very limited. How do you still not understand that? Nessie, are you suggesting that a piece of evidence from one witness may have more evidential value than ...
Caught from a mile and a half away? How? Did the evil nazis have camera sniffing bloodhounds that could track down cameras within miles of the facility, or what? Or was the smoke plume from the fires camouflaged somehow? What is the evidential value of there not being any Polish resistance photos ...
Notice that no exterminationist has addressed the monuments at the pond. I doubt they will. I did notice that Nessie is running away from the monuments at the pond issue. There is a question on the http://thisisaboutscience.com/ website that specifically addresses this. I wonder if Nessie has the ...
The reason why the mass murder of millions of Jews had been settled as fact, is because of the evidence. Yeah, "evidence" like this: https://pp.userapi.com/c844416/v844416052/625f4/IegR9AtMFC0.jpg https://img.ifunny.co/images/84b1c3382c548018431264b229765967f1acbb29483d791a166a1fc836de756a_1.jpg