Re: Why Do you Guys Think the Holocaust is Fake?
Posted: Mon May 05, 2025 8:35 pm
The 'gas chamber denial'ConfusedJew wrote: ↑Mon May 05, 2025 7:06 pm
The gas chamber denial is a separate sub-issue that we can maybe address later.

No, it is not. Census data before and after the war and insofar as tracking Jews in and out of Europe is notoriously unreliable, even if we assume it was not generally falsified. You're also neglecting the Soviet Union, notorious for its secrecy and 'Iron Curtain'. The bottom-line is that you cannot reasonably assert that we necessarily have evidence of 'where Jews did not go' en masse. They went everywhere.It's well documented which countries Jews went to after the war. Rarely did siblings and family members reconnect after the war but it did happen and those survivors had many of the same terrible reports as other people.
As our former forum moderator Hannover used to say, "Jews went where Jews are".
That's a very incomplete list. The Shoah Foundation archives alone include Jews who ended up in at least 60+ different countries. You're greatly understating the amount and range of global dispersion which occurred.What is very well documented is that hundreds of thousands of Jews were put into Displaced Person camps in Germany, Austria, and Italy until about 1952. A lot of displaced people went to the US, Palestine, Canada, South America, South Africa, and Australia. Some Jews returned to Eastern European countries like Poland, Hungary, and Romania but then they faced more anti-semitism and even pogroms so many left.
We are also only considering 'survivors', here. There are undoubtedly many who died by the end of the war or in the years that immediately followed, once in Soviet captivity (freezing winters, famine and disease continued well-after the end of the war, within the former Eastern-occupied territories). And Stalin was no friend of Jews nor minorities in general, having slaughtered millions.
We also have yet to consider Israel and that any secret agreements between victorious nations after the war may very well have coordinated transports to Israel, where demographic/population counts thereafter would be easily controlled by Jews and their collective interest groups.
Whereas I leave my conclusions partly open in terms of where each and every Jew ended up, it is you who claims they were all 'gassed' or shot into pits, indiscriminately. And it is your position who has the power and responsibility to prove your claims. Instead of doing that, you censor and persecute your critics.
Sorry, I used to preach the "not all Jews" line as well. The problem is that Jews have extreme and disproportionate power in major institutions. This is not even debatable, Jews often celebrate this publicly. They then use that power in ways that exclusively or overwhelmingly benefit Jews, to the extent that they can still maintain plausible deniability, in order to avoid negative attention upon Jews and Jewish interests.As long as people remain committed to truth and reason and objectivity, it doesn't matter what their pre-existing beliefs and biases are. Where I draw the line is on personal insults and clearly racist comments like maligning all Jews for doing things.
There is a longer history of these behaviors, here (primarily focused on the USA as of circa 2000), which I highly recommend, for anyone interested (disregard the color-coding of names, which does not come from the original author):
https://archive.org/details/WhenVictims ... 7/mode/2up
There are no massive protests by Jews against Jewish deception in media, none about Jewish influences in communism and other 'isms', about Jewish lobbying in Washington, about Jewish financial practices, etc. While there are a smaller number of "big Jews" at the top engaging in the most overt and problematic initiatives, the tribalism of Jews in general prevents the "little Jews" from counteracting initiatives which benefit Jews, even if unpatriotic and harmful to the host nation (e.g. USA).It is possible that people first come to disbelieve in the Holocaust and then become anti-semitic although that is still unacceptable in my opinion. I'm not sure why people here think the Holocaust was a "hoax" or who perpetuated it or why, but certainly not every single Jew so it's not fair to despise all Jews for the alleged actions of a few.
So no, "not all Jews" is not a sufficient policy in addressing the Jewish question. Jews in general have prioritized Jewish interests. More discussion on this topic, here:
'Criticism of Jews as a Collective (Not Just as Individuals) is Ethical and Warranted'
https://www.codohforum.com/viewtopic.php?t=144
Yes, very few Jews are the heads of these organizations, simply because the number of organizational heads is naturally very few. But the proportion of organizational heads who are Jewish is extraordinary and revealing. In any case, if these organizations were doing noble, patriotic things, we might have no problem with them being run by Jews. But we consistently find that quite often the most anti-American, problematic organizations have Jews at the helm (again, despite Jews as just ~2% of the population in the USA and even less abroad). See the link I just provided.Very few Jews are in the media, finance, warmongers, heads of NGOs. You will see the same exact things in any country that has developed a network of media, banks, NGOs. Jews are not necessary for that. People are aware of roughly how many casualties there were in WW2. I don't know why you are so upset that people know about the Jews who died?
It is absolutely not "historically false that Jews have been ejected from nations for hundreds of times throughout history". You're either ignorant or just being deceptive, full-stop.
It's historically false that Jews have been ejected from nations for hundreds of times throughout history, but even if it were true, who cares? Human nature tends to persecute people who are different from them and scapegoat those who don't deserve it when they don't understand their own problems or know how to deal with it. It's sad, but that's an actual indictment against humanity rather than Jewish civilization. Repeating that false claim, makes me question your accuracy and judgment overall.
As for "who cares?", such a pattern of ejections is necessarily concerning, given that we have multiple independent nations having serious problems with a visiting population. This strongly suggests the nations themselves are not the problem -- the visitors are.