Here's the answer to your question Archie

[Keen]

Archie:

Regarding the Kola study specifically... If you say that Kola faked the samples, this can come off as an admission that the reported results are somehow damaging to revisionism.

Why do that when it is not damaging?

https://codohforum.com/viewtopic.php?p=16363#p16363

Note: The question was asked about Belzec, but it applies to Sobibor as well.

Well Archie, compare this:

Callafangers:

I would concede a maximum of some ~40-50,000 [dead and burried] at Sobibor

https://codohforum.com/viewtopic.php?p=18609#p18609

To this:

Callafangers:

Here is mine [for Sobibor] (range goes from what I consider "reasonable minimum" to "absolute maximum"):

2,702 - 17,010

From 40-50,000 to 2,702 - 17,010 - that is a significant reduction, don't you think Archie?

See what happens when you focus on getting to the truth rather than trying to win arguments?

And even these lower figures Callafangers cravenly refuses to defend. (He's still running from Mr. Gerdes like a scared little girl.)

And why don't you ask Stubble what his once 25,000 figure is now down to?

And why don't you ask Callafangers why he's so afraid to answer the latest simple question that has been posed to him:

https://codohforum.com/viewtopic.php?p=21229#p21229

Perhaps you will anwer the question for us if Callafangers continues to cravenly refuse???

[Keen]

I thought this thread would be a good place for this:

Archie:

The Actual Jewish Death Toll:

Treblinka, Sobibor, Belzec, Chelmno:

"Hard to give specific figures but perhaps in the tens of thousands."

viewtopic.php?p=22684#p22684

A combined "tens of thousands" of deaths at these four camps?

Well then, break it down for us Archie:

Treblinka: _?_

Belzec: _?_

Chelmno: _?_

Sobibor: _?_

Total: "Tens of thousands"

Here's 7 of the "tens of thousands" Archie:



We know PRECISELY where these "tens of thousands" of dead jews are allegedly buried, don't we Archie?

Archie:

There seems to be some disconnect between the bottom-up and top-down figures. I'm inclined to think this is because of the unreliability (if not outright falsification) of the top-down figures, but this is hard to prove.

To push this further would require detailed demographic modeling

So why do this "demgraphic modeling" when all one has to do is look at each of the precisely known locations where these alleged "tens of thousands" of jews are allegedly buried?

There are only 93 of these precisely known locations at the four camps mentioned to look at, and I've aready shown you two and accounted for 7 of your "tens of thousands".

Why not just look at each of the 93 and simply count up what we find?

What could be simpler Archie?

Oh, a few important questions for you Archie:

Are any of these alleged "tens of thousands" of jews in liquid form?

Are any of these alleged "tens of thousands" of jews "magically disappearing jews"?

Does one need a pair of magic glasses in order to see these alleged "tens of thousands" of jewish corpses?

[Keen]

Archie, here is one of the 93 precisely known locations that we need to look at:

Treblinka "huge mass grave" F16:


I'm having a hard time seeing any of your "tens of thousands" of jews in "huge mass grave" F16 Archie.

Could you please point them out to us?

Edited to add:

Archie, lets add 7 more preciscely known "huge mass grave" locations to look at to make it an even 100.

Here are 7 more from Treblinka II:





Archie, could you please tell us how many of your "tens of thousands" of dead jews have been discovered in these 7 additional "huge mass graves"?